A few weeks ago, someone close to me called in a panic. A verbal agreement with the CEO of a potential client, on a very large deal, had come back in writing. The terms were not what they had agreed.
Their first instinct was to judge him. He was a liar. He couldn’t be trusted.
I understood the reaction. But a judgment like that gives the other person something to push back on, and it ends the conversation before it starts. So we slowed down and separated what we could observe from what we could not.
What we could observe: the written terms differed from the agreed ones. They had already taken the agreed terms to their own leadership, and those terms included significant concessions. They would not put the contract forward as written.
What we could not observe: everything happening on his side. Maybe his board was pushing for a better deal. We didn’t know, and we didn’t need to know to have the conversation.
I thought about this last week in Mexico City. At the National Museum of Anthropology, I stood for a long time in front of a replica of the headdress known as Moctezuma’s. I could see the quetzal feathers and the gold. I couldn’t see who made it or who wore it. Even the name is an assumption: there is no clear record that Moctezuma ever owned it. The story stuck anyway, because a story is easier to hold than a gap. We do the same with people, especially when we’re upset with them.
The process we talked through is one I have offered them many times before, and they have always found it a bit fluffy. It comes from Marshall Rosenberg’s Nonviolent Communication and has four parts:
Describe what you observed.
Say how it made you feel.
Name what you need.
Make a request.
This time the stakes were high enough to try it.
On the call, they stuck to the facts. They said the contract did not match what they had agreed. They said it left them confused and made it hard to trust, because it did not reflect that agreement. They explained they could not take it to their leadership in this form, and asked him to rewrite it according to the agreed terms. They spoke in I statements throughout, not you statements.
Afterward they sent me a message. It had been amazing, they said, because he couldn’t argue with anything they said.
I was elated. We had talked about this so many times. When I suggested NVC might need a new name, they wrote back that calling it “speaking invincibly” might do it, “seeing as the advantage of ‘I’ statements is they limit themselves to statements applying only to the speaker, which are irrefutable.”
They’re right. I statements are often treated as the polite option. In practice they are the hardest to dispute. “You misled us” invites a defense. “We agreed X, and this says Y” leaves the other person one useful move: to deal with the gap. Even when the facts are less clear, what you noticed and how it landed for you are still yours to state.
Being factual is not the same as being cold. It means you stop arguing about who someone is and start talking about what happened.
Conflict avoided is conflict amplified.
What conversation are you putting off, and what are the facts of it?
Bestest,
Patricia